Sunday, June 23, 2013

Was it all for nothing?


Many parts of our reading this week were emotional, thought provoking and inspired a wide range of reactions from me. The issues we face in today’s education system are controversial, diverse and constantly evolving. Local, state and federal regulations determine the proficiency of our system with guidelines that don’t take into account the reality that most kids live in today. Teachers feel overwhelmed, and underappreciated, as parents and students alike continue to underestimate the value of a good education and how hard we work to ensure their child is successful. However, there was one issue that I just keep thinking about and am unable to find a reasonable explanation for.

There simply is no way to equate what parents, teachers and children throughout history lived through as they fought for any kind of education compared to today’s society where everything is expected and handed over without delay. We teach every student in the United States. Regardless of whether you are rich, poor or any nationality under the sun, you have the opportunity to pursue an education. In this country you are provided with a public elementary, junior high and high school education without any cost to you. In addition, schools provide many extra curricular activities that ensure each interest has a venue of expression. Unfortunately, students of the past had to pave the road for those of us that came after them as they were denied this right over and over again. African American, Native American, Chinese, poor students, individuals that weren’t able to pass the faulty IQ test and female students all struggled to have the opportunity we believe we are entitled to without question. Unfortunately, I don’t think our society remembers the many sacrifices that gave us the right to have the free education we so easily take for granted.

I honestly don’t believe I could have sent my child to school knowing their life was constantly in danger. I am very appreciative of their bravery, and a little embarrassed to admit I couldn’t have done it. Ruby Bridges and her family paid dearly for the decision they made. They were no longer allowed to shop at the local store, her father lost his job and her grandparents were thrown off the farm they had worked for years.  Education meant something to these people! None of us has had to make sacrifices that could be life threatening just to get an education. Instead we have parents that complain, yell and write letters if they believe their child’s every want and need is not met to their satisfaction. I wonder what Mr. Bridges would say if he could walk into any school today and listen to a parent rant and rave because Johnny’s teachers hold him accountable.

How quickly we have forgotten the relatively short time we have had an organized education system in this country. Oftentimes students don’t want to go to school, and parents don’t have the fight left in them to make them go. We have children come to school every day without breakfast, clean clothes, brushed teeth or a bath. Teachers are expected to provide clothes, counseling, school supplies, food and tutoring to ensure each child is proficient. Where is the responsibility of the parent in any of this? I know there are many amazing parents in our districts. Parents that understand how important it is to learn to read and write so they provide learning opportunities at home on a daily basis. Then we have the parents, students and at times administration that simply do not see the relevance in what we are trying to accomplish. Why is this so hard to understand and appreciate when those dedicated men and women, who had relatively nothing, could see it 100 years ago?

3 comments:

  1. Barb,

    I totally agree and don't understand it either. There is such an entitlement in our country today. I saw a comic on FB the other day... on one side it was a picture of a parent -teacher conference in the past. The parents and teacher are asking the student to explain his bad grade. On the other side it is the same picture of a parent-teacher conference today and the parents are asking the teacher to explain the child's bad grade. The shift in accountability in incredible. I think too often we forget the gifts we have in this country like free and "equal" education for all. We forget where we started and the people who fought to get us here.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Barb,

    I totally agree and don't understand it either. There is such an entitlement in our country today. I saw a comic on FB the other day... on one side it was a picture of a parent -teacher conference in the past. The parents and teacher are asking the student to explain his bad grade. On the other side it is the same picture of a parent-teacher conference today and the parents are asking the teacher to explain the child's bad grade. The shift in accountability in incredible. I think too often we forget the gifts we have in this country like free and "equal" education for all. We forget where we started and the people who fought to get us here.

    ReplyDelete
  3. "Was it All For Nothing?" What a thought provoking question. I've actually been thinking about how to respond to that since you first posted. No, it wasn't all for nothing. Our problem is that we thought the fight was over. The Civil Rights Movement and the fight for educational equality of the 50's and 60's was just he beginning. As we have seen inequality still exists as does the scapegoating of teachers and education. National Defense Education Act, A Nation At Risk, No Child Left Behind, Idaho Stars, Students Come First, etc... Back in the day the people found their voice and stood up with courage and conviction. Where is our voice, courage, conviction. When Props 1,2,and 3 were first put forward the members of Meridian Education Association voted in favor of a 1 day walk-out in protest, just one day. Our leadership said only if Boise also walks. The day of the walk-out came, Boise backed out and the Meridian leadership crumbled. Where would we be today if the families of the Little Rock 9 had backed down? It was all worth it. The fight wasn't over with Brown V Board of Education. We took a couple of nasty shots with Nation at Risk and folks in power keep jabbing at us so all we can do is fight on and keep doing what we know is right for our students.

    ReplyDelete